The Decorated Gothic Cathedral: Building, Development, Reformation & Civil War

New Building to Completion of Nave

Less than one hundred years after the completion of the 12th-century cathedral, built in the Romanesque style, work began to transform Exeter Cathedral into the building seen today. Before the end of the 13th century, work had begun east of the old building to add new chapels and to enlarge the quire with a processional route behind the high altar. The twin towers of the old building were opened to form new north and south transepts, each with a chapel.

At the death of Bishop Walter Stapledon in 1326, most of the building work in the eastern part of the new cathedral had been completed. The magnificent 16-metre high carved oak bishop’s throne canopy and a wooden eagle lectern survive of the quire furnishings Stapledon paid for.

When the high altar was dedicated on Sunday 18 December 1328, the new Bishop of Exeter, John Grandisson, informed the pope that if the cathedral were completed it would be admired for its beauty above every other building of its kind in England or France. Bishop Grandisson then set about the task, rebuilding the western limb in a harmonious style.

Photo by Peter Smith, Newbery Smith Photography

The main construction of the nave was completed around 1342. Throughout the nave and in the western bays of the quire, the thick lower parts of the outer walls of the previous building were retained as the base for the thinner upper walls of the remodelled cathedral. External flying buttresses run the whole length of the building to brace the stone vaults.

The style is called ‘Decorated Gothic’. Here the designers enhanced the building with many different forms of window tracery, a rich variety of sculptured details and a forest of ribs in the vaults. Without a central tower to interrupt the internal space, Exeter Cathedral has the longest continuous medieval stone vault in the world, stretching 96m from the west wall of the nave to the east wall above the high altar. Wooden ceilings inserted in the older towers were painted white to harmonise with the plastered and painted stone vaults.

The builders also experimented with the patterns of window tracery. Much of this was the work of Thomas of Witney who was first consulted in 1313 about the bishop’s throne canopy. He was the master mason in charge from 1316 and throughout the construction of the nave.

Although not obvious at first glance, the windows in the south nave aisle are shorter than those in the north nave aisle. They needed to accommodate the now lost north cloister walk which was built along the south wall of the nave. However, the internal architecture of the cathedral as completed in 1342 is so harmonious, it makes these irregularities difficult to spot.

Work After 1342

Photo by Peter Smith, Newbery Smith Photography

The west front with its screen of statues followed the completion of the nave to provide a fitting entrance. The initial form of this ‘image screen’ with two rows of figures is considered the work of William Joy in 1342-47. His screen contains a hidden space. In 1369, Bishop John Grandisson was buried in the chapel set within the depth of the west front, to the south of the central doorway. We might think of him as eternally welcoming visitors to his great architectural achievement.

But Joy’s design was not completed by 1347, and some of the medieval figures in the lower two rows were later additions. The entrance porch of the north doorway was finished only in 1377, attributed to Robert Lesyngham who was appointed master mason that year. It contains the sole example of fan vaulting at Exeter, one of the earliest in the country.

Robert Lesyngham was also responsible for major work on the cloisters which took 20 years to complete. Archaeological evidence strongly suggests it was a full four-sided cloister. From 1414, the cathedral library was housed in the north cloister walk.

In 1390-91 the great east window above the high altar was described as ‘ruinous and shaky’. While the bottom lights and glass were retained, Robert Lesyngham replaced the upper wheel-shaped tracery with a more vertical Perpendicular style for which Robert Lyen provided new glass.

The chapter house, accessed from the east cloister walk, was described as a ruin in 1412, possibly from a fire. The early 13th-century lower walls with arcades were retained when the upper parts were rebuilt much taller with larger windows containing Perpendicular style tracery during the middle of the 15th century.

The west front image screen had a third upper level added in 1450-80 with another row of figures fronting an external gallery likely used by the choir to accompany processions into the west doors, such as on Palm Sunday. The west front was originally painted in vivid colours, a heavenly host of saints as a backdrop to the hundreds of burials in the grounds surrounding the cathedral.

The last building additions in this period were of two burial chapels between the buttresses of the easternmost bays of the south and north quire aisles. They were constructed before 1513 as chantry chapels in which priests prayed for the souls of Bishop Hugh Oldham (d. 1518) and Sir John Speke (d. 1519).

Spoilation

Exeter Cathedral had been established as part of the Roman Catholic Church. This was to change in the early 16th century when the Church of England initially split from Rome over disagreements between King Henry VIII and the Pope about the king’s marriages. This was part of a wider, evolving church reformation, which affected both the life and building of Exeter Cathedral.

The Dissolution of the Monasteries brought destruction to England’s monastic cathedrals, but Exeter was not among them. Yet it still suffered damage at this time. When King Henry VIII sought to eradicate Catholic practices, he appointed Simon Heynes as Dean of Exeter in 1537 to implement his reforms. Heynes removed brasses from the tombs of Bishop Lacy and Bishop Berkeley, sites of pilgrimage that were now banned by law. He also defaced cult imagery, such as the altar piece in Bishop Oldham’s chapel which depicted the vision of St Gregory.

The most significant changes came during the reigns of King Edward VI and Queen Elizabeth I. Chapels were abandoned or used as stores, their altars destroyed. Bishop Grandisson’s chapel in the west front was desecrated and his tomb robbed. Statues and other objects of devotion were removed or damaged, including figures on the great screen behind the high altar, and in the niches of the pulpitum. Vestments, altar frontals, and cathedral plate were also destroyed. By the end of the 16th century, Exeter Cathedral was transformed.

During the early 17th century sentiment shifted, and some repairs were carried out. The blank wall of the former high altar screen below the great east window was decorated with a perspective painting of the cathedral entrance flanked by the figures of Moses and Aaron. The central image was of the Ten Commandments posted on doors symbolising the Gates of Heaven.

The upheavals of the English Civil War and the abolition of the monarchy led to the closure of all cathedrals in England. The City of Exeter changed hands several times during the Civil War. During one of the periods of Puritan control, cathedral services were suspended for 9 months between December 1642 and September 1643. Early in 1643 local citizens broke into the cathedral and set about damaging windows and some of the carved figures.

Eventually, bishops were abolished by Act of Parliament in 1646. The abolition of deans and chapters followed in 1649 when their properties, including cathedrals, were forfeited. Exeter Cathedral’s medieval cloisters were sold and demolished by 1656. Domestic buildings later occupied their four sides.

The cathedral and chapter house were the responsibility of Exeter’s city chamber. In late 1657, the city chamber paid for a brick dividing wall to be constructed in the cathedral to enable different groups of non-conformists to hold their services in the cathedral at the same time. A doorway was created in the east wall of the Speke chapel to provide an entrance into the eastern part.

When the cloisters containing the cathedral library were about to be demolished a local physician rescued the cathedral’s collections of books and manuscripts and in 1657, the city chamber gave him permission to use the former Lady Chapel to house the collections.

When King Charles II reclaimed the throne in 1660, the English Church was restored, including the return of bishops, deans and chapters in cathedrals. The brick wall dividing Exeter Cathedral was demolished and cathedral services resumed. Work began on repairing and embellishing the building. The king instructed that cathedral property should be returned to ecclesiastical use. However, the domestic buildings now in Exeter’s cloisters complicated the matter.